
When
Essence Magazine did a poll asking its readers the question, this is the result:
--Ask him what he did time for. It could be harmless
86 %
--Keep him as a friend, but nothing more
9 %
--Tell him something suddenly came up and head for the door
3 %
Some answered like this:
"I am dating someone with a record i didint know at the time people make mistakes and turn their lives around he is a wonderful person."
My comment: Yes, many people do turn their lives around. The recidivism rate, the statistics that tell how many prisoners return to jail after their first arrest is 60%. According to Wikipedia: recidivism: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recidivism 60%
• Released prisoners with the highest rearrest rates were robbers (70.2%), burglars (74.0%), larcenists (74.6%), motor vehicle thieves (78.8%), those in prison for possessing or selling stolen property (77.4%), and those in prison for possessing, using, or selling illegal weapons (70.2%).
• Within 3 years, 2.5% of released rapists were arrested for another rape, and 1.2% of those who had served time for homicide were arrested for homicide. These are the lowest rates of re-arrest for the same category of crime.
• The 272,111 offenders discharged in 1994 had accumulated 4.1 million arrest charges before their most recent imprisonment and another 744,000 charges within 3 years of release.
Sociologist Roger Roots has suggested that computer accessibility of criminal records is helping people make decisions about staying out of jail. Before the computer revolution, people with criminal records were often able to relocate and start their lives over in new communities.
"Former criminals rose to become some of America's greatest leaders in law, industry, and politics. This possibility seems to be narrowing as criminal records become electronically stored and accessible." They cannot pass the background check of most jobs.
According to the
Washington Post,"The growth in prison population is largely because of tougher state and federal sentencing imposed since the mid-1980s. Minorities have been particularly affected: One in nine black men ages 20 to 34 is behind bars. For black women ages 35 to 39, the figure is one in 100, compared with one in 355 for white women in the same age group."
Here are some women's responses to this issue and my comments. I am choosing male prisoners as an example, but it applies to women too. If you are a male would you date a women who has been in prison?
"I am dating someone who has a record. However this was done during his juvinile years. We all make mistakes some more than others, we are not not defined by our past;but the choice to choose the direction of our future."
My comment: I agree, lots of people do stupid things before they are 20. It depends on what kind of crime. If they have repeatedly raped, bludgeoned, killed, molested children--I would pass on them. There are enough men who don't have these complications. This goes especially for child molesters, who have difficulty restraining themselves from offending again. According to
Prentky, Lee, Knight, and Cerce (1997), over a 25-year period, child molesters had higher rates of reoffense than rapists (52 percent versus 39 percent over 25 years) .
One woman responded like this:
"It depends on what it was and how long ago it was. If he was convicted of rape, robbery, child molestation or any violent crime; the answer is unequivocally no. I know people make mistakes and can change but I can't take that chance."
My comment: Yes, I agree. You can't take that chance. Have some self-esteem and know you can attract someone who is not deeply flawed.
Another lady responded this way:
"A person is defined by the content of thier character. I am engaged to a wonderful man of great principle who spent all of his formative years in a juvenile prison for a violent crime. He used the sentenced time wisely to develop spiritually and attend college. He is an intelligent, hardworking, gainfully employed, God-fearing, and loyal partner. His qualities are what most women long for in a mate. Ironically, his brother who accoding to my soon to be mother-in-law "never gave her any trouble," is having an affair for the fourth time in his five year marriage, squandered away all of he & his wife's savings, & dragged his wife into his IRS troubles. Guess he saved all of his trouble for the wife? It's not always where you have been but where you are going."
My comment: This is a very wise answer. You have to see how people behave over time. This man obviously learned his lesson and won't repeat his mistakes. The brother-in-law sounds like one of The Dirty Seven. He just got lucky and avoided the slammer.
Another lady states:
"I have recently met a man that served federal time for drug dealing. He is a brillant man,loves god and his children. He works, and owns his home. He has been out since 2004. My ex-husband of 12 years carries none of this man's traits. I don't know if serving time has made him humble, or what. This man stimulates my mind. We are not sexually active, and he has not pressured me whatsoever."
My comment: Again, this man has learned his lesson and deserves a second chance. Plus, his crime was non-violent. The jails are full of people for drug use and dealing, while child molesters and wife beaters walk the streets because they have gone unreported. In may cases, however, child molestation goes unreported. Estimates are that only 35% of sexual abuse is reported http://www.childmolestationvictim.com/statistics.html. Kids can be frightened or embarrassed and many times do not say anything.Almsot half of domestic battery victims do not report it either. http://www.snbw.org/articles/unreported_violence.htm
Another lady responds:
"yes, my boyfriend will be getting home in 4 days. his first time in trouble and jail/prison. i've known him for 10 years now - way before he made a stupid mistake that landed him into prison. our relationship is off and on but supposedly now it is all the way on (for last 2 years). he spent the last year in prison and now i have to wait and see if he is truly serious about us being together. he is very intelligent, loyal, protective and motivated. so let's see what the future holds as we do love each other and trust that the future will be good to him as he deserves it. not sure i would be willing to do this with him if i hadn't known him prior to prison sentence as i have a young daughter to consider."
My comment: Women bring all kinds of men into their lives because they are desperate, lonely, horny, or have low self-esteem. When you have children, you must think about how the new man will impact them. It depends on what this man's "stupid mistake" was because violent criminals have a different psychological profile than drug users or thieves. Psychopaths, for example, are characterized by the fact that they don't learn from their actions. blame others, and persist in destructive behavior.
Here is a thought-provoking response:
"It depends on the reason and the length of time incarcerated, as well as how many times he has been in jail/prison. My biggest concern after those aforementioned would be his HIV status. Lets not kid ourselves ladies. The "everyone makes mistakes" attitude is cool, but dont be oblivious to what goes on in correctional facilities when men get a little lonely, whether it is consensual or not. It's bad enough we have to worry about the "down-lows" and the "I'll sex anything that moves" men that have never been locked up."
My comment: Anyone who has been to prison knows they better not "drop the soap" in the shower, or leave their nether regions unprotected from people doing hard time with nothing to lose. HIV is a very big concern and this lady is intelligent to bring it up. As for the "down-lows," I will discuss this in another article. They are known as GuyMan, one of the Dirty Seven (link to where have all the good men gone). This lady is also correct in evaluating how often the man has been in prison because that tells about his ability to learn from his "mistakes."
And finally, another woman's attitude is:
"I am in a great realtionship with a gentlemen that has done time. I knew him before he had to leave and he actually came home to me after several years. We are still together and honestly I have never been happier. I hear all the stigma behind men that have done time but I agree with the others if you have known this person long before hand and you have been thier support system, I don't see the problem. Everybody makes mistakes and deserves a second chance at happiness!!"
My comment: How long you have known the person, have observed this person, and his values is the determining factor here. My philosophy has been you must see how the person behaves over time. Not what he says. Not what he says he'd like to do.
This is a very complicated issue and each case must be judged individually. You are the one who has to consider all the factors. If you are with this man because you can't find anyone else and you are lonely--be aware that this weakness within yourself can open you and your children to a dangerous future. If you know this person, the circumstances of their incarceration, and the growth they have achieved because of this experience, then you might give him a chance.
Labels: dating men in jail